Mixed Greens Blog

Mixed Greens Blog
Living Sustainably in the Pacific Northwest


Savory and Sweet: Salted Caramel Ice Cream

caramelicecream19 of 33

It’s already August and if you haven’t used your ice cream freezer yet, the time has definitely come. There are very few multi-generational activities that evoke as many summer childhood memories as making and eating ice cream. Those of us who are lucky enough to live in the Seattle area not only have access to all sorts of delicious ingredients for making our own ice cream, there are also several shops where you can buy hand-crafted locally made ice cream (I’ll give you a list at the end of this post). Think balsamic strawberry, Vivace coffee, fennel seed, Olympia marionberry even Estrella Farms “Partly Sunny Blue Cheese” with hazelnuts. With all of these tempting flavors locally available, why make your own? Because it’s fun and that’s what summer is supposed to be all about.

caramelicecream3 of 4

I chose to make Salted Caramel Ice Cream after seeing a recipe on gourmet. com. Granted, it’s a little on the sophisticated side for kids but with a couple of chocolate chips sprinkled on top, Lily was more than happy to be my taster. The complex flavor of this intriguing combo depends on getting the salty-sweet balance just right. Don’t be tempted to add a couple sprinkles of salt on top, this recipe is right-on just the way it is.

lilyicecream12 of 15 The first step is making a “dry” caramel which is basically melted sugar — tricky because it is super-hot and reportedly hard to control. If you pay attention during this fairly fast process and don’t try to multi-task, it’s surprisingly easy and gorgeous to look at. My custard, on the other hand, turned into sweet scrambled eggs on my first go-round. I now think that was because I was using raw milk (from Dungeness Valley Creamery). I’ve since noticed that raw milk tends to thicken faster, even when heating it for my tea. I can’t find any evidence to document this as a problem in general when cooking with raw milk. It certainly tastes great but I had to toss my first batch of custard. Second time around, I added the hot milk to the eggs VERY slowly and had much better results.

saltedcaramelicecream4 of 21

Salted Caramel Ice Cream Recipe

1 1/4 cups sugar, divided

2 1/4 cups heavy cream, divided

1/2 t flaky sea salt

1/2 t vanilla extract

1 cup whole milk

3 large eggs

Heat 1 cup sugar in dry, large heavy skillet (using a light color skillet allows you to see the color of the caramel more easily) over medium heat, stirring with a fork to heat sugar evenly, until sugar starts to melt. Once it’s melting, stop stirring, pick up the pot (using pot holders, of course) and swirl it around so the sugar melts evenly. It’s done when all the sugar is melted and it’s a dark amber color.

Add 1 1/4 cups cream and cook, stirring until all the caramel is dissolved. When you first add the cream, the caramel may initially become a big lump. Don’t worry, just keep stirring and it will eventually dissolve. Remove from the heat, transfer to a bowl, add sea salt and vanilla and let cool to room temperature.

Bring milk, remaining cup cream and remaining 1/4 cup sugar just to a boil in a small heavy saucepan, stirring occasionally.

Lightly whisk eggs in a medium bowl, then add half of the hot milk mixture in a very slow stream, whisking constantly. Slowly pour this mixture back into the saucepan with the remaining milk over medium heat. Stir constantly with a wooden spoon until it thickens and coats the back of the spoon. Pour custard through a fine-mesh sieve into a large bowl. Stir in cooled caramel.

Chill custard several hours (3-6), stirring occasionally, until very cold.

Freeze with ice cream freezer following the freezer directions. Once it’s frozen, transfer to an airtight container and store in the freezer to firm up. It will keep about 1 week.

saltedcaramelicecream15 of 21

List of Hand-Crafted Ice Cream in the Seattle Area

Molly Moon’s Homemade Ice Cream – Molly has shops in Wallingford and Capitol Hill. Every time I’ve driven by the Wallingford shop there’s a line out the door so it must be really good. They “combine creamy dairy from happy, healthy, hormone-free Western Washington cows with sweet and savory ingredients” and “focus on seasonal fruits and herbs.”

Poco Carretto Gelato is a “mobile gelato cart that offers up to 10 delicious gelato and 6 sorbetto flavors using local and organic ingredients made by Chef Holly Smith of the award winning restaurant, Cafe Juanita.” They sell at several farmers markets and cater private events.

Bluebird Homemade Ice Cream and Tea Room This neighborhood cafe and ice creamery on Capitol Hill is focused on bringing people together. Their ingredients are “almost entirely local, organic whenever possible.”

Empire Ice Cream Once again, local and organic rules. You can find them at the Ballard Sunday Farmers Market, the University District Farmers Market, Eat Local and the Paragon Restaurant & Bar.

Half Pint Ice Cream ” A small, owner-operated homemade ice cream company.” Their “ice creams are made fresh weekly with local dairy and eggs and other local ingredients when possible.” They sell at several farmers markets in our area.

I hope I haven’t left any one out. I know there are others not that far from home because every time I go to Orcas Island I pick up at least one flavor of Lopez Island Creamery Gourmet Ice Cream. Yum!

lilyicecream1 of 15

Tagged as: , , ,

8 Responses »

  1. We love FULL TILT in White Center and Columbia City in Seattle.
    Yummy flavors and paletas (mango chili and blackberry cinnamon) – ice cream flavors run from chocolate, vanilla, Mexican chocolate, mango chili, mint chocolate chip, strawberry, blackberry dark chocolate chip, butter pecan, hazelnut, birthday cake with real cake and frosting IN the ice cream”) and two vegan flavors — mango sorbet and coconut coffee. Paletas will be $1.50; ice cream starts at $2.25 a scoop. Check out there mypace page at http://www.myspace.com/fulltilt_icecream

  2. I love using my ice-cream maker, even though I make sorbets rather than ice-cream (I’m off dairy)… I’ll have to play around with a caramel flavor and see if I can get it to work. Any thoughts?
    There are some local ice-cream makers here too who also sell sorbets, but making ones own is a way to really customize the flavors, use odd combos, and just enjoy the process.

  3. Rockergirl, I was hoping some readers would help me fill in my list. Thanks for letting us know about Full Tilt.
    Mangochild, I googled caramel sorbet and found several recipes using just water, sugar, vanilla & salt. This fall it’d be tempting to replace some of the water with apple juice. Let me know if you have success with the sorbet.

  4. I still think that homemade often beats the best creative stuff you can get at the any commercial establishment. Homemade ice cream during summer is one of the things I miss most right now while raw eggs are still taboo. Jerry Traunfeld was making ice creams flavored with lemon verbena and with thai basil at the Capitol Hill market a while back … they sounded exquisite.

  5. Audrey, I agree with you. I rarely go out to eat anything these days. Part of it is financial but mostly I think homemade is best. Hopefully there will still be some warm ice cream days after your baby comes in Sept.

  6. How about bainbridge island ice cream? Aren’t they a local maker? Just curious if you have heard anything about them…

  7. Oh ya, and what about snoqualmie???

  8. Kiran, I think the ice creamery on Bainbridge is called Mora. I know they make it all there but I’m not sure where their ingredients come from. Snoqualmie is a great suggestion. They support local farmers whenever possible. Thanks for thinking of these and adding to our list.